Skip to main content

Table 5 Results associated with changes in the input elements

From: Automation in cargo loading/unloading processes: do unmanned loading technologies bring benefits when both purchase and operational cost are considered?

 

Loading plate

Transport belt

Skate + 

Scenario A (Increase of 5% of volumes every year)

Return on investment after 10 years

5%

13%

No positive ROI

Estimated break-even period

3 years and 2 months

2 years and 8 months

No break-even point reached

Scenario B (Increase of 15% of labour cost)

Return on investment after 10 years

13%

22%

No positive ROI

Estimated break-even period

1 year and 3 months

1 years and 9 months

No positive ROI

Scenario C (increase the technology risk from 0 to 15%)

Return on investment after 10 years

3%

10%

No positive ROI

Estimated break-even period

4 years and 2 months

3 years and 4 months

No break-even point reached

Scenario D (Using a 100% loading degree of trucks)

Return on investment after 10 years

4%

41%

16%

Estimated break-even period

3 years and 8 months

5 months

2 years and 4 months